Essential Guide to Reading Biomedical Papers: Recognising and Interpreting Best Practice – Book Review

Life sciences have become an indomitable force in science and they exert an inordinate amount of influence on the wider world as well. Medical research has a wide-ranging set of implications for the society in general. Research paper in medicine and related fields have proliferated almost beyond bounds in recent years, and it makes it hard for even the experts and the insiders to fully understand and be on top of the recent findings. The process of peer review provides some amount of checks and balances on the quality of those papers, but the mare fact of publication should not be an indication of the quality of research, or even its accuracy. Ultimately the burden of determining these important aspects of biomedical research rests on the readers of those papers, which in most cases are other scientists and researchers.

This collection of articles on biomedical papers is intended primarily for the practitioners of this kind of research. It is written with a graduate student and/or recent entrant into the field. The book is a collection of “primers” on various techniques and laboratory practices that are encountered in most modern biomedical research. It is fairly comprehensive and covers most of the main research paradigms now in use. Each “primer” is written as a self-contained paper, all with introduction, charts, conclusion and references. Information in this book is detailed, well backed up and constructive. It’s a useful collection to have around in any personal research library.

My main objection to this volume concerns the quality of writing. Scientists are not necessarily known for their prose, but even with these relatively low standards I think this collection suffers from not being terribly well-written and well-organized. Many authors jump from one idea to the next with almost careless abandon. The topics are often not too well organized, and the authors assume too much of an inside knowledge from its readers. The book could have certainly used a fair dose of content and presentation editing.

This book provides a lot of useful information, but pedagogically it falls short.

 

Bojan Tunguz

Bojan Tunguz was born in Bosnia and Herzegovina, which he and his family fled during the civil war for the neighboring Croatia. Over the past two decades he has studied, lived and worked in the United States. He is a theoretical physicist with degrees from Stanford and University of Illinois. Tunguz has taught physics at several prominent liberal arts colleges and has been writing about physics, science and technology for more than a decade. He also has a wide spectrum of interests, and reads and writes about current events, society, culture, religion and politics. Over the years he has reviewed many of the books that he has read, and posted his reviews on various online outlets. In 2011 he had become a top 10 reviewer on Amazon.com, where he continues to be very active. Aside from reading and writing, Tunguz enjoys traveling, digital photography, hiking, and fitness. He resides with his wife in Indiana. You can follow my review updates on the following pages as well: Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/tunguzreview Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/tunguzreviews Google+: https://plus.google.com/u/0/104312842297641697463/posts

Visit Website

There are no comments yet, add one below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*